Copyright © 2004 Bill Wilkinson. All rights reserved. counter free hit unique web

Rennes-le-Chateau text bar

Rennes-le-Chateau text bar

Rennes-le-Chateau text bar

Hidden Details of Rennes-le-Chateau

Rennes-le-Chateau text bar

Rennes-le-Chateau text bar

Rennes-le-Chateau text bar

Rennes-le-Chateau text bar

Rennes-le-Chateau text bar

Rennes-le-Chateau Books and Related Items for sale

Rennes-le-Chateau text bar

 

Comparison of the Stations of the Cross in Sauniere's Mary Magdalene church to those appearing in other Churches in the area.

Stations of the Cross 2 & 3

Station 2 - Jesus takes up His Cross.

rennes-le-Chateau Station 2  Couiza Station 2

Rennes-le-Chateau Station 2                                                                           Couiza Station 2 

View Larger images of the Stations of the Cross 2

For some reason, Sauniere has altered the position of Jesus's left arm, the angle of his head and his clothes. Jesus now points at a small rock on the ground between the Centurion's feet. Feet, rock, foot of a rock or a mountain perhaps? The building in the background has also been removed from Saunière's, though he has a painted version. No right hand of Jesus on the cross. No pole with three circles. There are a few other minor differences but even with these differences the overall view is similar.

Rocamadour Station 2      Rennes-le-Chateau Station 2

Rocamadour Station 2                                                                  Rennes-le-Chateau Station 2         

The main differences between this Station is that in Sauniere's Station 2 we have two extra men, one of them holding a shield up high. Other differences include: The position of the left arm of Jesus. The cross is smaller. The man on the left with the raised arm looks in a differant direction. A helmet beneath the kneeling figure. Jesus's right hand no longer holds onto the cross. A rock has been added between the feet of the Centurion.

rennes-le-chateau station 3    rennes-le-chateau station 7

Rennes-le-Chateau Station 3                                                                      Couiza (Station 7)    

Interestingly, Station 3 at Rennes-le-Chateau does not match station 3 in Couiza church but station 7, shown above. So I will use station 7 for comparison here as it is the one we need to compare. Sauniere's choice of framing has cut off a small amount of detail. We are left with the following differences in Sauniere's Station 3: The robes Jesus is wearing have changed. The soldier in the foreground is now wearing a helmet and is looking in a different direction, his arm position has changed from Jesus's right shoulder to his left, his footwear has been removed as has his breastplate. The two men in the background on the right have also undergone a change of clothing. No hand holding the highest part of the cross here. Though the three men on the right appear in both these stations, all have undergone changes. The standard in the background has been removed and so has the arm holding a sword. A man now blows a long curved horn or trumpet.

Couiza church station 3      Rocamadour Station 3

           Couiza (Station 3)                                                                                      Rocamadour Station 3    

Station 3 appearing in Couiza Church. (Left) This will be discussed in the Station 7 comparison.

Rocamadour Station 3 (right) at first glance bears a resemblance to Sauniere's but the differences are obvious, a few of which I will mention here. In Sauniere's Station 3 there is no horse, 8 men instead of 5, no hand on the top of the cross beam, different clothing. It looks as if Couiza church has positioned and labeled it's station 3 incorrectly, getting the second fall of Jesus mixed up with His first fall. Notice the similarity of the raised arm of the man extreme left with the similar positioned man in the Rennes-le-Chateau Station 2.

  Jean d'Alcas church 2

Mouthoumet                                               Jean d'Alcas

View Larger images of the Stations of the Cross 2

As you can see from the Mouthoumet and Jean d'Alcas church stations, they are by far the best match for Saunière's Mary Magdalene church stations of the cross. Apart from a few minor details they are an exact match. What we must bare in mind though, is which church did these designs appear in first? If Sauniere's were the first then perhaps it is of no importance how many churches the stations later appear in. Unfortunately, Saunière's are the only stations we know the date they were installed.

Click to find out more about Pontius Pilate, Roman Prefect (26 C. E. -36 C.E.)

Illustrated Guide to Rennes-le-Château No1 - Stations of the Cross, Bas-Reliefs, Statues and more

 

Rennes-le-Chateau Research Rennes-le-Chateau Updates Rennes-le-Chateau Timeline Rennes-le-Chateau Book Store Contact